Self-reliance and CS
The Christian Way Forums
 Home          Members     Calendar     Who's On

Welcome Guest ( Login | Register )
        



Self-reliance and CS Expand / Collapse
Message
Posted Friday, November 23, 2007 3:47 PM Post #14165
 

OldtimerOldtimerOldtimerOldtimerOldtimerOldtimerOldtimerOldtimer
I am halfway through Clarence Thomas' book, My Grandfather's Son: A Memoir. In his autobiography, Thomas walks the reader step by step through his life experiences, which are truly remarkable when viewed in light of the fact Thomas started out an illegitimate black child born into poverty in the deep South back when prejudice and segregation were truly a way of life -- and he ended up a Supreme Court Justice for the United States. What's so fascinating is that he takes the reader through his thinking process as he grows up full of rage, becomes invoved in the radical black movement, and finally turns into a conservative.

One theme I'm seeing as I read is that Thomas realizes that self-reliance, as opposed to reliance on things like quotas and government handouts, is an important key to overcoming poverty and social prejudice. It got me thinking about the self reliance I was taught in CS. I don't recall specifically being told to "rely on yourself" in CS, but I think that's the underlying message behind a mindset that guarantees success if one will only learn how to correctly apply a set of principles such as CS -- at the same time teaching a person to downplay and even live in denial of negative symptoms and circumstances in an attempt to demonstrate their nothingness. It's a fact that CSists are usually fairly successful people, and I have heard it argued that "it's easy to be CS when you're well off and naturally healthy." I agree with this, but I'm also wondering if the overall mindset of "self reliance" fostered by CS helps propel people to financial success.

Anyone have any thoughts on the subject?

Posted Saturday, November 24, 2007 11:12 AM Post #14166
 

OldtimerOldtimerOldtimerOldtimerOldtimerOldtimerOldtimerOldtimer
It is true that naturally robust health is a real asset to the effective "practice" of CS.  I believe that a great deal of CS "healing" is a kind of Darwinian "fellowship of the fittest."  I myself have an immune system that is the envy of my in-laws: no allergies, rarely sick, and brief and minor colds and flues when I am sick.  The flip side:  I have to consciously avoid being critical or impatient with other people when they do get sick. ("Memo to self:  your wife really is sick!")

It is true that a positive sense of personal self-worth, competence, and confidence have a beneficial effect on the general course of one's life.  But CS takes this to an unnatural extreme, declaring that all of one's life's quality is determined by one's degree of spiritual attainment.  Obviously, natural adversity and authentic personal limitations will play their part.  CS cheerfully claims ("affirms"?) that everything can be overcome--and if it isn't, then whose fault is that, anyway?

I had a recent chat with a guy who was getting deep into CS's metaphysical kin, the health-and-wealth gospel of Benny Hinn and kin.  I challenged him with this question, applicable to CS:  "Take this teaching into the concentration camps of Third Reich, the Soviet Gulags, the Chinese prison camp-factories.  And maybe a cancer hospice as well.  Will it deliver success, freedom, prosperity and health in these places?"

Authentic Christianity is for everybody, whatever his station: the rich and poor, the strong and weak, the rich and poor.

Posted Monday, November 26, 2007 7:27 AM Post #14175
 

OldtimerOldtimerOldtimerOldtimerOldtimerOldtimerOldtimerOldtimer
Moderator's note: Posts 14171 - 14173 were off topic and have been moved to a thread entitled Off-topic posts from "Self-reliance and CS" thread.
« Prev Topic | Next Topic »


All times are GMT -7:00, Time now is 4:10am

Powered By InstantForum.NET v4.1.4 © 2009
Execution: 0.062. 10 queries. Compression Disabled.